Does a Spindle with Scarring and Complete Bearing Failure Need to be Replaced
Question:
Hi, i was heading to a lake when i notice white smoke coming out of my trailer ,I stop and notice that the ruber on dust cover of the hub had a hole and the grease was coming out,the spindle greaser was sticking out ,looked like the wheel move to the inside of the axle, turn a round since I was 6 miles from home.I dissassamle the wheeal hub,but first notice that it had lots of movements in and out.the inner bearing was gone all the rollers were mix with the grease...so the spindle had some scars not many but some .do you think a can get away by changing for a new of yours hub and drum assambly ,code #84546uc3 ??less than 21 days ago my trailer was service for the same thing on the other side wheel ,they put a new hub assambly and repack all the other hubs,including this one?,thanks
asked by: ed r
Expert Reply:
What concerns me about this situation is the scarring on the spindle. Depending on how deep and how bad the scarring is, a new set of bearings and a new hub/drum assembly might experience the same problem down the road. This would mean that the spindle would need to be replaced also. Otherwise, you may have to frequently replace parts. It would be best in this situation to eliminate the possibility of future similar occurrences before they have a chance to cause damage. Any visible scarring or heat spots, coupled with the complete bearing failure, do indicate that you will need to replace the spindle.
To find the correct replacement spindle, there are some measurements that need to be taken. Take a look at the link to our trailer spindle main page below. You will see a drawing of a spindle with the 6 measurements (A through F) that are needed to find the correct replacement spindle. The old spindle will need to be removed and the new one installed by a qualified welder or shop that works on trailers. You may also need a new brake mounting flange welded on as well. I have included a link to our brake mounting flanges as well.
With the correct replacement spindle installed, I can determine the correct bearing kit and hub and drum assembly for the trailer. If you want to only replace the hub and drum, to find the correct replacement, you will need the inner and outer bearing numbers. Since the inner bearing is missing, you can find it by removing the other hub and checking the bearing numbers on that side. I have included a video below on inspecting trailer bearings below. Additional helpful information would be the bolt hole pattern of the wheels and the size of the wheel and tire. I have included links to FAQs below on finding this information.
Product Page this Question was Asked From
Square #84 Spindle for 3,500-lb Trailer Axles - 1-1/2" Wide
- Trailer Spindles
- Standard Spindle
- 1-1/2 Inch Diameter
- Square
- For 3500 lb Axle
- TruRyde
more information >
Featured Help Information
Miscellaneous Media
Continue Researching
- Video: Demco Cast Head Coupler with Jack Hole Review
- Shop: Trailer Idler Hub Assembly for 2,000-lb Axles - 4 on 4 - Galvanized
- Video: Review of Timken Trailer Bearings Races - L44649 and L44610 Set - TMK23VR
- Shop: Bulldog Heavy-Duty Cast Head Coupler w/ Wedge Latch - 2-5/16" Ball - A-Frame - 15,000 lbs
- Shop: Dexter Trailer Springs Over-Under Conversion Kit
- Shop: Dexter Trailer Axle with Idler Hubs - 4 on 4 Bolt Pattern - 60" Long - 2,000 lbs
- Q&A: Coupler Repair Kit for 1987 Airstream with 2-5/16-Inch Trailer Coupler
- Shop: Grease Seal - Double Lip - ID 1.719" / OD 2.565" - for 3,500-lb Axles - Qty 2
- Shop: #84 E-Z Lube Spindle w/ Brake Flange for 3,500-lb Trailer Axles
- Shop: Timken Bearing Kit, L44643 Inner/Outer Bearings, L44610 Inner/Outer Races, 204507 Seal
- Q&A: Recommended Disc Brake System for Salt Water Boat Trailer with Tandem Axles
- Video: TruRyde Bearing Kit for #84 Spindle Installation
- Video: Timbren Axle-Less Trailer Suspension System Test Course
- Video: Redline Trailer Brakes BRKH12 Review
- Video: TruRyde Electric Trailer Brake Kit Installation
- Video: Dexter Axle Trailer Brakes - Electric Drum Brakes - 23-112-113 Review
- Q&A: Increasing Ground Clearance on Trailer with Drop Spindles
- Q&A: Torque Specification for 12 Inch Wheel with 4 Lug Nuts on Boat Trailer
- Search Results: grease
- Q&A: Removing Trailer Bearing that is Stuck on Spindle After Removing Hub
- Q&A: Replacement Hub for Tie Down Engineering 11033
- Search Results: deemaxx
- Article: Slipper Spring Trailer Suspension System Review
- Search Results: oil bath
- Search Results: bearing buddy
- Q&A: Can I Replace a 4.80-8 Trailer Tire with a 4.80-12 or 5.30-12 Trailer Tire
- Search Results: equalizer
- Search Results: shackle straps
- Search Results: hanger
- Article: 5 Tell-Tale Signs It’s Time to Replace Your Trailer’s Leaf Springs
on Trailer Spindles
