Best Affordable 3-Bike Trunk Mounted Rack for 2015 Kia Soul
Question:
What are the differences between the Hollywood Rack Express 3 and the Thule Passage 3 Bike carrier? We will almost always carry just two bikes, but may have a third on a rare occasion. Should we just get a two bike carrier or is three ok for transporting two almost all the time? If we were to get a two bike carrier, which would you recommend? Do you have a recommendation for the KIA, which we will tow behind an RV and drive by itself? Thank you.
asked by: Melanie H
Expert Reply:
It's better to have the capacity and not need it, than wonder "where will we put this third bike?" The extra weight capacity of the 3-bike version will also pay off in the long run since they're designed to be slightly sturdier than the 2-bike versions. The main downside is the extra length so keep that in mind when you're parking or backing into spaces with just the Kia Soul.
As for choosing which one, first the Hollywood Racks Express # HRE3, while a confirmed fit, I do not recommend for your 2015 Kia Soul. It is missing anti-sway features that are so important to keep your bike secure.
The Thule Passage 3-Bike Rack # TH911XT is a great rack. It has the same weight capacity of 35 lbs per bike. What's special about the Passage # TH911XT are two things. The first is the FitDial system where Thule has specific settings for each vehicle. The FitDial setting for the 2015 Kia Soul is 11. The second is how the arms are adjusted separately. If you are carrying one alternate frame bike like a children's or women's bike, this works great with keeping it level without an adapter bar like # TH982XT.
If I had to choose, I prefer the Thule Passage 3-Bike Rack # TH911XT because of its different design features. It has those cool rotating arms and is a good looking bike rack. It is also nice not to need an adapter bar if carrying a single alternate framed bike. It comes with the important featuere of anti-sway cages to prevent bike-to-bike contact.
Whichever one you find works best for your needs, you will need a separate cable lock like # e98891. You'll also need an extra strap like # e98876 to tie down your bikes since they will be on the highway. Make sure to reduce as much sway as you can especially from the front tires.
Products Referenced in This Question
etrailer Cam Buckle Cinch Strap w/ Buckle Protector - 1" x 13' - 293 lbs - Qty 1
- ATV-UTV Tie Downs
- Trailer
- Truck Bed
- Padded Buckles
- 1 Strap
- Manual
- 11 - 20 Feet Long
- Cam Buckle Strap
- Cinch Strap
- 0 - 1 Inch Wide
- 176 - 350 lbs
- etrailer
more information >
etrailer Cable Lock - 10' Long - 5/16" Diameter - Steel - Keyed Alike
- Cable Locks
- Utility Lock
- Keyed Alike
- Steel
- 10 Feet Long
- etrailer
more information >
Hollywood Racks Express 3 Bike Carrier - Fixed Arms - Trunk Mount
- Trunk Bike Racks
- Frame Mount - Standard
- 3 Bikes
- Non-Retractable
- Locks Not Included
- Does Not Fit Spoilers
- 6 Straps
- Non-Adjustable
- Hanging Rack
- Hollywood Racks
more information >
Product Page this Question was Asked From
Thule Passage 3 Bike Carrier - Trunk Mount
- Trunk Bike Racks
- Frame Mount - Anti-Sway
- 3 Bikes
- Non-Retractable
- Locks Not Included
- Fits Most Factory Spoilers
- 6 Straps
- Adjustable Arms
- Hanging Rack
- Thule
more information >
Featured Help Information
Instructions
Miscellaneous Media
Continue Researching
- Shop: Yakima HangOut 3 Bike Rack - Trunk Mount - Adjustable Arms
- Shop: Yakima FullBack 3 Bike Rack - Trunk Mount - Adjustable Arms
- Shop: Saris Bones EX 3 Bike Rack - Trunk Mount - Adjustable Arms
- Q&A: Yakima FullBack for 2020 Toyota RAV4
- Video: Yakima Trunk Bike Racks Review - 2016 Jeep Cherokee
- Search Results: allen
- Q&A: What is the Difference Between a Class II and a Class III Hitch?
- Article: How to Choose the Right Trailer Hitch Class
- Video: Choosing the Right Trailer Wiring
- Search Results: hitch
- Shop: etrailer Hitch Pin Alignment Collar for Hitch Accessories - 2" Hitches
- Shop: Trailer Hitch
- Shop: Curt Powered Tail Light Converter with 4-Pole Flat Trailer Connector
- Search Results: trailer hitch
- Video: Yakima FullBack Adjustable Trunk Bike Rack Review - 2020 Audi Q7
- Article: Trailer Wiring Diagrams
- Shop: Trailer Wiring
- Shop: Roof Rack
- Shop: Universal Installation Kit for Trailer Brake Controller - 7-Way RV and 4-Way Flat - 10 Gauge Wires
- Video: Yakima FullBack Hanging 2 Trunk Bike Rack Review - 2019 Toyota RAV4
- Article: Brake Controller 7- and 4-Way Installation Kit (ETBC7)
- Video: Yakima FullBack Trunk Mount 2 Bike Rack Review
- Shop: Suspension Enhancement
- Article: My Trailer Hitch Doesn't Fit
- Shop: Redarc Tow-Pro Liberty Brake Controller - Dash Knob - 1 to 2 Axles - Proportional
- Video: Yakima FullBack 3 Bike Rack Review
- Shop: Brake Controller
- Article: How to Measure for Trailer Hitch Drop
- Video: Yakima HangOut 3 Bike Rack Review
- Article: Rooftop Cargo Carriers